Monday, August 1, 2011

Falling out of love with my Christmas Kindle

Finally Blogger has decided to keep me logged in, so I can comment this evening (so far only on my own blog, but I'm hopeful it will last). Here, as promised, is my Kindle post:

That honeymoon didn't last long. Don't get me wrong, I'm still fond of the Kindle's good points - particularly the germ free reading and the knowlege nobody will ever again be able to throw my entire book collection into a skip (we all know what happened, so I'm not going to keep going on about it, but there are some things a person should never forgive).

But, but, but...

As the weeks have gone on, I've identified things I'm not too happy with:
  • It's awkward to hold. Several times, as I've drifed off to sleep, it's fallen and hit me in the eye. A real book has never done that.
  • The Kindle is a machine. I've heard stories - horror stories - of people being left with NOTHING TO READ when their Kindles have broken down.
  • Cost of books: Some of the Kindle versions can cost as much as or slightly more than the paperback version. I know there's VAT on Kindle books. But there are no printing costs, distribution costs, storage costs or costs associated with shelf space, so the old-bag-book-keeper in me thinks this is ludicrous and unfair.
  • The American version, I believe, allows friends and family to borrow books. I wouldn't lend a book out illeagally, ever. But, as the technology's available, it would be nice if I could let friends borrow books from my Kindle, just as they can with my real life library.
  • Worryingly, there have been reports Amazon have taken to sensoring books retrospectively. Or deleting books altogether. They've always had a good excuse, either the material is questionable or there's a query over rights. But the very fact they are able to do this worries me. This is the equivalent of them knocking at the door to demand the return of a real book - and I've never heard of that happening.
  • A Kindle doesn't feel like a real book. It doesn't smell like a real book. It doesn't give me goosebumps when I pick it up, like a real book does.
  • This is what's disturbed me most I think: Amazon have gone all 1984ish and are spying on our reading habits through our Kindles. When we download books, information must be fed in the opposite direction, too, because they can show me passages that other readers have highlighted. They know what I read and when - and probably use the information as a force for evil, relentlessly marketing. I'm not fond of being spied on.
  • And I've been left wondering, if I download my own work onto my Kindle so I can read before submitting, will Amazon be tempted to fiddle with that? I know that makes me sound big headed - surely Amazon have much better things to do than fiddle with my WIPs. But, when I was a teenager, I asserted my individuality by wearing a variety of badges on my school blazer - one of my favourites announced:  'Just because I'm paranoid doesn't mean they're not out to get me'. And it's true.
Having said all that, I think the Kindle is a great supplement to real books. I'll certainly be hanging onto mine for dear life - particularly for the convenience of having so many book in such a small space. But, if I'm considering a book that costs more than a few pounds, or a book I know is a keeper, I'll be going the real route every time.

19 comments:

Fran said...

I'm trying to get used to seeing people with their Kindles on public transport, but I just can't! It looks like they are all reading the same silver book!

Pearson Report said...

I'm still a pager turner and I tend to utilize the services of my local library! Our beautiful, well stocked main library, in town, is incredible - so far it has always managed to fulfill my request for a book...then it conveniently forwards it to the nearest branch (close to where I work) and I'm good to go!

On a funny note...I laughed when you mentioned the "germ-free" aspect of your Kindle...I wipe the outside of my borrowed books with little alcohol wipes - not much I can do with the pages inside...so I wash my hands before doing anything else. I know, I'm weird!

Nonetheless, in your last paragraph, your first sentence echos my sentiments..."it makes a great supplement to real books".

These Christmas romance often fizzle out mid summer! (chuckling!)

Great read - really enjoyed this post.

Cheers, Jenny

Carla Swafford said...

One drawback to e-readers is an author can't see if they're reading her book. LOL!

Diane Fordham said...

I guess it has its place, but nothing like the real thing!

DittyMac said...

I've had hardcover and paperback books fall on my face when I fell asleep. But I am sure the Kindle hurt worse.

Diane Fordham said...

Lol DittyMac, that was funny!

joanne fox said...

Those Big Brother aspects do sound worrying.

I can see the convenience of Kindles, but I'd still sooner have a dog-eared library paperback even with whatever germs, crumbs or dead flies lurk between the pages. And as you say, if something goes wrong with the Kindle then you're stuck. Not much can go wrong with a book, unless you drop it in the bath, in which case it would still be legible - if a little crinkly.

Teresa Ashby said...

Love it! I'm sorry but I laughed about the Kindle hitting you in the eye - the times I've gone to sleep clutching a book I know that would happen to me too.

I've downloaded Kindle on my PC but I haven't got the actual gadget - yet.
(I dropped a library book in the bath once - it took ages to dry it out and when I took it back it was about four times as big - I still haven't forgotten the guilt!)

And I don't like the 1984 element either!
Glad you're back Suz!

Lacey Devlin said...

I was all set to get a Kindle for Christmas 2011 but then I caught a video of Angela James and one of her pieces of advice was to try the handsets out to make sure they're comfortable in your hand. It's funny how you don't think of these things. I certainly don't want a Kindle in the eye ;-)

Romy said...

You fall asleep while reading? I have the opposite problem ... I start reading, and never get any sleep!

Debs Carr said...

Great post, and sorry, but I also had a giggle about your Kindle hitting you in the eye, as that sounds so like something I'd do.

I love my Kindle and it was perfect to take on holiday in the place of books. That said, I did end up buying three books when I was away.

So, I suppose, I do love my Kindle, but giving the choice prefer paper books.

billyblogger said...

Kindle reading is a dangerous business - only for the brave! But do you read on your back holding it up in the air? Sounds uncomfortable. I'm a leaning on elbow man - you can prop it up against something that way. I love my Kindle but I still love real books too. If they cost more on Kindle I simply buy the real thing instead. Personally I also like the feel of it and find it easier to hold than a real book - especially a hefty hardback. But each to their own!

DittyMac said...

@BillyBlogger. You must be youngish. The elbow thing makes your hands go numb later on in life.

Amanda said...

HA HA - Your post made my day! So funny! I can just imagine your Kindle falling on your face as she drift off to sleep - not that that made my day, you understand. I'll stop now, shall I? x

billyblogger said...

I feel youngish, Ditty, but I'm actually oldish. So that's why my hand's gone numb. I thought it was something else. Phew.

Suzanne Jones said...

It does look odd, doesn't it, Fran.

Hi Jenny - I use those wipes on books, too :0)

That's true, Carla. And very hard for authors to sign copies, too.

Very true, Diane.

It hurt a lot, DittyMac :0)

I do like real books, Joanne, but not so fond of the germs :0)

Hi Teresa - I think you'd like the Kindle - despite my whinging, it's very convenient and much easier to read than a computer screen. Probably wouldn't work after a dip in the bath, though :0)

That is very good advice, Lacey.

I don't always sleep so well, Romy, so a book distracts me until exhaustion takes over :0)

Me too, Debs. And I've done the buying books thing while I've got my Kindle in my handbag. Buying real books is a very had habit to break. :0)

Hi billybogger - generally curled up on my side with the kindle resting on a pillow - and it still fell and hit me. And you make a good point about the hefty hardback - I'm sure that would hurt more than the Kindle.

Hi, Mandy. I know what you mean :0)

Virginia Llorca said...

Thank you for your suggestion re: my blog. Much appreciated.

womagwriter said...

This is interesting, thanks for posting your thoughts on the Kindle. I am just considering buying one. However I'm a book-sniffer and so I know that the Kindle could never replace my serious book-buying habit. But may it could supplement it. In particular, I can imagine taking a Kindle on holiday loaded up with plenty of books, so I don't have to worry I'd run out of reading material.

Suzanne Jones said...

You're welcome, Virginia.

Hi womagwriter - the Kindle is definitely useful for holidays. And handbags - you'll never be without something to read again (unless - and I hate to write this - it breaks down).

XX